President Donald Trump’s contemplation of U.S. military involvement in the ongoing conflict between Israel and Iran is generating significant division among his core supporters, particularly within the “Make America Great Again” (MAGA) movement.
Despite previously denouncing prolonged military engagements in the Middle East, Trump now appears increasingly open to deploying American forces to support Israeli operations targeting Iran. His shift in tone has prompted backlash from some of his most prominent allies.
Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene, a vocal Trump supporter, expressed strong opposition. “We are sick and tired of foreign wars,” she posted on social media, asserting that those supporting deeper U.S. involvement no longer represent the America First agenda.
Other influential conservative voices including Tucker Carlson, Steve Bannon, and former Congressman Matt Gaetz have also spoken out against military action. Carlson, in particular, criticized pro-intervention Republicans and warned that Trump’s decision could define his presidency. He has argued that the U.S. should step back and allow Israel to handle the conflict on its own.
This internal conflict has even led to rare bipartisan cooperation. Congressman Thomas Massie, a Republican, introduced a resolution in the House aiming to block U.S. involvement in the war. It quickly attracted support from progressive Democrats, including Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.
Trump has not remained silent. He took to social media to dismiss Carlson as “kooky” and continues to receive support from neoconservative Republicans, such as Senators Lindsey Graham and Mitch McConnell, who have long advocated for a strong U.S. role abroad.
Tensions are also surfacing within conservative media circles. Greene has publicly criticized Fox News and the New York Post for supporting military action, while Carlson has used his platform to question GOP hawks like Senator Ted Cruz.
Vice President JD Vance, known for his skepticism toward foreign interventions, has attempted to mediate. In a public statement, he encouraged supporters to trust Trump’s judgment, assuring that any military engagement would serve U.S. interests alone. Notably, Vance’s deputy press secretary is Buckley Carlson, son of Tucker Carlson.
Recent polling reflects the uncertainty among Trump voters. A YouGov survey found that 53% of Trump supporters oppose U.S. entry into the conflict, with only 19% in favor. However, public sentiment could shift if military operations begin, historically triggering a rally-around-the-flag effect.
Still, critics warn that a misstep could fracture the movement. Analysts suggest that if the conflict leads to prolonged U.S. involvement or American casualties, backlash from Trump’s base could be severe.
The unfolding situation presents one of the most significant challenges to Trump’s coalition since his return to office. How he navigates the divide may have lasting implications for both his presidency and the broader conservative movement.
