Committee Advances Face Covering Penalty Bill
An Idaho legislative committee voted to move forward a bill that would increase criminal penalties for individuals who wear face coverings while committing a crime.
The proposal advanced by a narrow margin and will continue through the legislative process for further consideration.
What the Bill Would Do
The legislation would allow courts to impose additional penalties on individuals convicted of crimes committed while wearing face coverings.
Under the proposal, offenders could face:
- Up to one additional year in prison
- An added fine of up to $2,500
- Or both
The enhanced penalties would apply to both felony and misdemeanor offenses, but only if the underlying crime is proven in court.
Definition of a Face Covering
The bill defines a face covering as any mask, hood, or device that covers or conceals part of an individual’s face.
Supporters acknowledged that the definition is broad but emphasized that penalties would only apply in connection with a criminal conviction.
Supporters Cite Public Safety and Investigative Challenges
Supporters of the bill told lawmakers that wearing face coverings during crimes can make investigations more difficult and embolden criminal behavior.
A representative from local law enforcement testified that the use of facial disguises during criminal activity occurs regularly and complicates identification efforts, even if exact frequency data is unavailable.
Concerns Raised Over Prosecutorial Discretion
Some lawmakers expressed concern that the bill gives prosecutors and judges significant discretion when applying the enhanced penalties.
Critics warned that, if misused, the provision could be applied to relatively minor offenses. Supporters countered that enhancements are rarely applied without serious justification and rely on judicial oversight.
Legal Perspective on the Proposal
A law professor from the University of Idaho College of Law told lawmakers that similar laws exist in other states and noted that the bill requires proof of an underlying crime before any additional penalty can be imposed.
However, concerns were raised that the enhancement could substantially increase sentences for certain misdemeanor offenses, depending on how it is applied.
Clarifying Claims About the Bill’s Origins
During the committee hearing, claims were raised suggesting the legislation was connected to foreign governments or religious organizations.
Bill sponsors and other lawmakers rejected those claims, stating that the proposal is focused solely on criminal conduct and public safety and has no connection to outside political or religious entities.
What Happens Next
The bill will now move forward for additional legislative review and debate.
Lawmakers are expected to continue discussing how the measure would be applied in practice and whether additional clarifications are needed before a final vote.
Related Coverage
Idaho News – https://idahonews.co/idaho-news-3/
National News – https://idahonews.co/national-news/
About the Author
