Why It Matters
Idaho pumps $2.5 billion annually into public education, but the formula that determines how those dollars reach individual schools was written more than three decades ago. For rural districts — which make up more than half of Idaho’s high schools — the gap between what the formula delivers and what it costs to operate a school has grown increasingly difficult to close.
With enrollment patterns shifting and fixed operating costs rising, many school administrators say the attendance-based model leaves districts short-funded on days when students happen to be absent, even though the lights, buses, and staff remain on the payroll.
What Happened
Idaho Superintendent of Public Education Debbie Critchfield and State Senator Dave Lent (R-Idaho Falls) gathered with education stakeholders Thursday at the College of Eastern Idaho in Idaho Falls to hear concerns and ideas about reshaping the state’s school funding structure.
The meeting was part of a broader series of listening sessions held in Idaho Falls, Boise, and Coeur d’Alene, stemming from Senate Concurrent Resolution 121, which the Idaho Legislature passed directing state leaders to examine modernizing the funding formula. School administrators, teachers, and parents attending the Idaho Falls session pushed for a shift toward enrollment-based funding, which would tie revenue to the number of students on a school’s roster rather than daily attendance counts.
The core complaint is straightforward: a school’s fixed costs — building maintenance, utilities, bus routes, and permanent staff — do not shrink when a student stays home sick. The current formula, however, can effectively penalize a district for absences it cannot control.
By the Numbers
- $2.5 billion — Idaho’s annual investment in public education
- 32 years — the age of the current attendance-based funding formula
- 50 percent — the share of Idaho high schools classified as rural
- 3 cities — locations where in-person listening sessions have been held: Idaho Falls, Boise, and Coeur d’Alene
- June 25, 6–8 p.m. — date and time of the upcoming virtual Funding Formula Modernization listening session
What Leaders Are Saying
Critchfield was direct in her assessment of the status quo. “Our current funding distribution isn’t getting the job done,” she said during the session.
Senator Lent framed the push for reform as a matter of keeping pace with how Idaho communities and families have changed. “When we talk about modernizing the funding formula, what we’re trying to do is catch up as our society and culture has evolved,” he said.
Marcy Curr, a teacher with 18 years of classroom experience, was among the educators who participated in Thursday’s discussion. Her perspective reflected a common thread throughout the session: that the people closest to students — teachers and building-level administrators — have watched the funding model fall further out of step with operational reality year after year.
Zoom Out
The funding conversation comes as Idaho school districts are already navigating financial headwinds. Several districts across the state have trimmed staff heading into the next school year as enrollment declines in some areas and costs continue to climb. A formula that does not account for fixed operational costs amplifies those pressures, particularly in smaller rural communities where there is little financial cushion.
Idaho’s rural school challenge is significant in scale. When more than half of the state’s high schools serve rural populations, a funding model designed for a different demographic era can produce real disparities in what students receive depending on their zip code.
The Legislature’s passage of SCR 121 signals bipartisan recognition that the 32-year-old formula needs a serious review, though the specifics of any new model remain to be worked out through the stakeholder process now underway.
What’s Next
A virtual listening session is scheduled for June 25 from 6 to 8 p.m., giving Idahoans across the state an opportunity to weigh in without traveling to one of the in-person locations. State leaders are expected to use input gathered from all sessions to inform legislative proposals in the next session. No specific draft formula has been released publicly at this stage.
About the Author
