Independent Senate Candidate Challenges Jim Risch to Three Public Debates Before November Election
Why It Matters
With Idaho’s U.S. Senate race now set following Tuesday’s primary, the question of whether voters will see candidates debate face-to-face before November is front and center. Independent candidate Todd Achilles is pushing for three public debates, arguing Idaho voters deserve a direct comparison of candidates on the issues.
What Happened
Achilles announced Wednesday that he is formally requesting incumbent U.S. Sen. Jim Risch participate in a series of three statewide debates scheduled for August, September, and October ahead of the Nov. 3 general election. The announcement came the morning after Risch secured the Republican nomination with nearly 67% of the vote against three primary challengers.
In addition to Achilles and Risch, the general election field includes independent Natalie Fleming, Democrat David Roth, and Libertarian Matt Loesby. Risch’s campaign had not responded to the debate challenge as of Wednesday.
“Idaho deserves a public debate,” Achilles said in a press release. “Idaho voters have been denied the opportunity to see candidates stand side-by-side, answer tough questions, and defend their records in front of the public.”
Risch’s Debate History
Risch’s participation in public debates has been inconsistent over the years. He took part in a Zoom-format Idaho Public Television debate ahead of the 2020 general election, appearing alongside Democratic and independent opponents. Before the 2014 general election, he participated in a single televised debate on a Boise-area news station.
However, Risch has also declined debate invitations in the past. In his 2006 lieutenant governor campaign, he refused to appear in a live public television debate after the station declined his request to answer questions separately from his opponent, citing concerns about what he described as potentially “disruptive behavior.” In 2008, he similarly skipped a public television primary debate while opting for a taped format instead.
By the Numbers
- Risch captured nearly 67% of the Republican primary vote Tuesday, defeating three challengers
- 5 candidates are now confirmed in the Nov. 3 general election
- 3 debates proposed by Achilles — one each in August, September, and October
- Risch has participated in at least 2 general election debates in prior Senate campaigns (2014, 2020)
Zoom Out
Incumbent senators in solidly red states frequently face limited pressure to debate, particularly when challengers lack major-party backing. Risch has held his Senate seat since 2009 and is widely considered a strong favorite heading into November. Still, with statewide fundraising contests already heating up, the race is drawing attention across Idaho’s political landscape.
The presence of multiple independent and third-party candidates alongside the Democrat could add complexity to the general election dynamic, giving debate organizers more logistical factors to navigate.
What’s Next
Risch’s campaign will need to formally respond to Achilles’ debate proposal. Any debate scheduling would need to begin soon if the August target is to be met. Idaho voters will head to the polls November 3 to decide the Senate race.
About the Author
