Wyoming Mule Deer Hunters Push Back Against Lifting Antler Restrictions Biologists Say Are No Longer Necessary
Why It Matters
Wyoming’s mule deer herds represent one of the West’s most prized wildlife resources, drawing hunters and outfitters whose livelihoods depend on healthy deer populations. The ongoing debate over hunting regulations in northwestern Wyoming’s Sublette and Wyoming Range herds is pitting hunter instinct against biological science — with real consequences for the state’s wildlife management credibility and outdoor recreation economy.
The outcome will also signal how Wyoming balances public sentiment with data-driven wildlife policy, a question that resonates across the Mountain West as natural resource pressures mount throughout the region.
What Happened
The Wyoming Game and Fish Department proposed rolling back emergency hunting restrictions it imposed following the devastating 2022-23 winter, which decimated mule deer populations across northwestern Wyoming. The department’s draft 2026 hunting regulations call for extending hunting seasons and eliminating antler-point restrictions for the Sublette and Wyoming Range mule deer herds across 18 hunt areas.
The proposed changes would undo a shortened season and a minimum four-point antler requirement that Game and Fish put in place starting in 2023 to protect bucks in the wake of catastrophic winter kill. Biologists now say those protections are no longer needed — and that keeping them will not meaningfully accelerate herd recovery.
Despite the agency’s biological rationale, a majority of hunters who submitted public comments have opposed lifting the restrictions, expressing concern that relaxing protections too soon could undermine years of painstaking recovery progress.
By the Numbers
- The Wyoming Range herd crashed from 29,580 deer before the 2022-23 winter to a low of approximately 10,300 — a loss of roughly two-thirds of the population.
- After the 2025 hunting season, the herd had rebounded to an estimated 15,500 animals, still about half of its pre-disaster peak.
- In fall 2023, hunters killed an estimated 416 deer with a 16% success rate — the slowest season in 30 years.
- By fall 2025, success improved to 27%, with hunters harvesting 992 buck deer — still well below the pre-winter average of 1,661 bucks per season.
- Current buck-to-doe ratios stand at 43:100 in the Sublette herd and 38:100 in the Wyoming Range herd, within biologically acceptable ranges.
The Science vs. The Sentiment
Brandon Scurlock, wildlife management coordinator for the Wyoming Game and Fish Department’s Pinedale Region, acknowledged the severity of the 2022-23 winter but said the data now supports liberalizing hunting opportunities. “It was a devastating winter, by all accounts,” Scurlock said. “But we are bouncing back.”
Biologists point out that population recovery in deer herds is driven by does producing fawns and those fawns surviving — not by buck numbers. Since female and fawn mule deer cannot be legally harvested in either herd, changes to buck hunting seasons have no expected impact on population trajectories unless sex ratios become severely imbalanced. Current ratios do not meet that threshold.
Still, hunters like Afton resident Tristan Mack pushed back in public comments. “While we have 5,500 more deer, which is great progress, I fear that beginning to take away restrictions too soon may regress the progress that has been made,” Mack wrote. Blake Gipson of Diamondville said he is “vehemently opposed” to the changes, questioning why the state would extend seasons and lift antler restrictions while the population remains far below historic levels.
Not all hunters opposed the rollback. Cora resident Braxton Hamilton cited the data directly, arguing antler restrictions “tend to be most beneficial over a short period — roughly three years — and can become counterproductive when extended beyond that timeframe.” Teton County resident Glenn Owings offered “strong support” for ending antler requirements, writing that “that strategic effort has run its course.”
Zoom Out
The conflict reflects a broader challenge facing wildlife managers across the Mountain West: communicating science-based decisions to a passionate public with a deep personal stake in conservation outcomes. Hunters in Wyoming have long been among the most conservation-minded stakeholders in state wildlife management, and their resistance to liberalization — even when biologists say it’s appropriate — illustrates how trust built during a crisis can complicate later decisions.
Wyoming’s mule deer herds are also part of a larger ecological picture. Habitat pressures, migration corridor integrity, and weather volatility are ongoing concerns that wildlife agencies must weigh alongside annual harvest decisions.
What’s Next
Wyoming Game and Fish commissioners are scheduled to make the final call on 2026 hunting regulations for the Sublette and Wyoming Range mule deer herds — along with regulations for all Wyoming elk, deer, and pronghorn herds — at a meeting on Wednesday, April 22 in Casper. Meeting details are available at WGFD.wyo.gov/commission.
Biologists caution that even under favorable conditions, a full recovery of the Wyoming Range herd to pre-2022-23 levels will likely take several more years. Hunters, they say, will need to remain patient as the herds continue to rebuild.
About the Author
